Obrázky stránek
PDF
ePub

be reserved, of revoking a former limitation of a use, and of appointing a new use to some other person.

7. In an opinion of the late Mr. Booth, which has been published by Mr. Hilliard at the end of Sheppard's Touchstone, is the following account of contingent uses and powers :-" By the old law, no fee simple could be limited upon or after a fee simple; but, since the statute of uses, executory fees by way of use have not only been allowed, but are become frequent, in all conveyances operating by way of transmutation of possession. The uses are served out of the seisin of the feoffees, grantees, releasees, &c. In all future or executory uses there is, the instant they come in esse, a sufficient degree of seisin supposed to be left in the feoffees, grantees, &c. to knit itself to and support those uses; so as that it may be truly said the feoffees or grantees stand seised to those uses, and then, by force of the statute, the cestui que use is immediately put into the actual possession. It is wholly immaterial how, or by what means, the future use comes in esse: whether by means of some event provided for, in case it happened in the creation of the uses, which event may be called the act of God; or by means of some work performed by any certain person, for which provision was likewise made in the creation of the uses, which may be called the act of man; in either case the statute operates the same way; for the instant the future use comes in esse, either by the act of God or the act of man, the statute executes the possession to the use, and the cestui que use is deemed to have the same estate in the land, as is marked out in the use, by the deed that created it. When the use arises from an event provided for by the deed, it is

called a future, a contingent, an executory use: when it arises from the act of some agent or person nominated in the deed, it is called a use arising from the execution of a power. In truth, both are future or contingent uses, till the act is done; and afterwards they are, by the operation of the statute, actual estates. But till done, they are in suspense, the one depending on the will of heaven, whether the event shall happen or not; the other on the will of

man."

8. If a person conveys his estate by lease and release to trustees and their heirs, to the use of himself for life, remainder to his first and other sons in tail, and inserts a proviso in the release, that it shall be lawful for him, at any future time, to revoke these uses, and to declare new ones; and that immediately upon such revocation and new declaration, the trustees shall stand seised of the lands to the use of such persons as the settlor shall appoint; this is a power of revocation and appointment. As soon as it is 'executed, the uses originally limited cease, and a new use immediately arises to the person named in the appointment, for such estate as is given to him by it; and the statute transfers the legal estate to such appointee, who by that means acquires the actual seisin and possession.

The nature of revocations and appointments to Tit. 32. c. 13. uses will be explained hereafter.

the Statute

of Uses.

Bac. Read.

33.

9. Lord Bacon says, the chief object of the statute Conveyances of uses was to destroy all those secret conveyances to derived from uses which had been so much complained of." The principal inconvenience, which is radix malorum, is the diverting from the grounds and principles of the common law, by inventing a mean to transfer lands and inheritances without any solemnity or act noVOL. I. Ff

1 Atk. 591.

Read. 39.

torious; so as the whole statute is to be expounded strongly towards the extinguishment of all conveyances, whereby the freehold or inheritance may pass, without any new confections of deeds, executions of estate, or entries." It is therefore somewhat singular that the statute, instead of having had that effect, has given rise to several new modes of transferring lands, unknown to the simplicity of the common law; and of a more secret nature than feoffments to uses: so that, notwithstanding the great caution with which this statute was made, it has not answered the intention of the Legislature.

10. Lord Bacon has, however, clearly proved, that the intention of the statute was only to destroy the estate of the feoffee to uses, by transferring it to the persons who were entitled to the use; and not to destroy the form of the conveyance to uses. 1. Because the words of the statute are, "Where any per son is seised, or hereafter shall be seised to any use, &c." 2. In the same session in which this statute was made, it was enacted, that all bargains and sales to uses should be enrolled; which proved the intention of the Legislature, to leave the form of the conveyance, with the addition of a farther ceremony. 3. By the twelfth section of the statute, it was provided that the king should not take any primer seisin, or other feudal profits, on account of any estate which should be executed by means of the statute, till the 1st of May 1536. But that he should take the feudal profits for all uses which should become executed by the statute after that time.

11. Whatever might have been the intention of the Legislature in passing this statute, it is certain that it has given rise to several new sorts of convey. ances, which operate contrary to the rules of the

common law for it being soon observed that there was nothing in the statute to prevent the raising of uses, but only a provision that when a use was raised, the possession of the land should be transferred to such use; it was only necessary to raise a use, and the legal seisin and estate, together with the actual possession, became immediately vested in the cestui ante, c.3. $ 40. que use, without livery of seisin, entry, or attorn

ment.

12. In consequence of this doctrine, it became customary to raise a use to the person to whom the lands were intended to be conveyed, and then the statute transferred the possession to the cestui que use. This was done in two different ways; first, by a conveyance which only transferred a use, and which is said to operate without any transmutation of possession, because the alteration of the legal seisin is effected by the mere operation of the statute. There are two modes of conveyance which operate in this manner: a bargain and sale to uses, and a covenant to stand seised to uses; of which an account will be given in Title XXXII. Deed.

13. The second mode of conveying lands through the medium of uses, is effected in the following manner: the legal estate and possession is transferred by a feoffment, fine, or recovery, to some indifferent person, who stands in the place of the ancient feoffee to uses; a deed is then executed, reciting, that by such feoffment, fine, or recovery, the lands have been transferred to A. B., and declaring that such feoffment, fine, or recovery shall enure and operate, and that the feoffee, cognizee, or recoveror in such feoffment, fine, or recovery, shall be seised of such lands, to the use of a third person. Or else a deed is first executed, reciting that a fine or recovery is intended

c. 9 & 10.

c. 12.

Whether the

Statute ex

to be levied or suffered, or covenanting to levy a fine
or to suffer a recovery; and declaring that these as-
surances, when completed, shall enure to the use of
a third
person.

14. In both these cases a use arises out of the seisin of the feoffee, cognizee, or recoveror, to the person to whom such use is declared, and the statute immediately transfers to that use, the legal estate and actual possession.

15. These latter assurances are said to operate by transmutation of possession, because the legal seisin and estate is first transferred by some common law conveyance or assurance. They are usually called deeds to lead or declare the uses of a fine or recovery, and will be treated of in Title XXXII. Deed.

16. As the statute of uses preceded the statute of tends to De- wills, the former has been said not to extend to devises to Uses. vises to uses. It is however observable, that the

Dyer, 127 a.

Case,

1 Leon. 253.

words of the statute of uses are,-"Where any person, &c. is seised to the use of any other person by reason of any bargain, sale, &c. will, or otherwise." Now, though at the time when this statute was made, the word will could only apply to wills of lands then devisable by custom, yet when the statute of wills passed, the word will in the statute of uses became applicable to wills, or rather devises, of all the lands over which the testamentary power was given.

17. In a case in 2 & 3 Phil. & Mary, it is said that devises of land in use have been common. In E. Hartop's 23 Eliz. it was agreed by the Court of Wards, that a devise might be to the use of another; and Lord Coke is there reported to have been of opinion, that the son of a devisor takes by descent, when the cestui que use, to whom the land is devised, refuses the use; for the devisee cannot take it to his own use, because,

« PředchozíPokračovat »