REPORTS OF CASES

DETERMINED IN

THE SUPREME COURT

OF THE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA,

W. W. COPE,

REPORTER.

VOLUME 63

WITH

NOTES ON CAL. REPORTS

SAN FRANCISCO:

BANCROFT-WHITNEY COMPANY,

LAW PUBLISHERS AND LAW BOOKSELLERS.

1906.

Entered according to Act of Congress in the year 1884, by
SUMNER WHITNEY & CO. AND A. L. BANCROFT & CO.
In the office of the Librarian of Congress, at Washington.

COPYRIGHT, 1899,

BY BANCROFT-WHITNEY CO.

COPYRIGHT, 1905,

BY BANCROFT-WHITNEY CO.

COPYRIGHT, 1906,

BY BANCROFT-WHITNEY CO.

SUPREME COURT.

R. F. MORRISON, Chief Justice.

DEPARTMENT ONE.

E. W. McKINSTRY, Presiding Justice.
S. B. MCKEE, Associate Justice.
E. M. ROSS, Associate Justice.

DEPARTMENT TWO.

J. D. THORNTON, Presiding Justice.
M. H. MYRICK, Associate Justice.
J. R. SHARPSTEIN, Associate Justice.