Obrázky stránek

Page Krughoff, Robert M., president, Washington Center for the Study of Services

308 Laue, Douglas, deputy chief, California State Bureau of Auto motive Repair

48, 83 Ligon, W. H., managing director, Texas Service Station Association

369 Livingston, Charles F., Acting Associate Administrator for Traffic Safety

Programs, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Department
of Transportation

5, 143, 188 McCarthy, Frank E., executive vice president, National Automobile Dealers Association-NADA.

212 McDowell, D. James, managing director, Automotive Engineering and Road Services Department, American Automobile Association.......

48 Mallon, Robert P., president, National Automobile Dealers AssociationNADA

212 Mizak, Raymond M., general manager-service, American Motors Corp.. 429, 459 Moretti, Therese, Addison, Ill.

477, 491 O'Neill, Brian, vice president for research, Insurance Institute for Highway Safety ..

511 Pansa, O. Robert, director, service section, consumer relations and service staff, General Motors Corp

429 Persley, Allen S., Houston, Tex ......

367 Pipes, Larry A., on behalf of the American Automobile Association of Missouri

..... 143, 179 Raftery, William A., president, Motor and Equipment Manufacturers Association

36 Randall, Donald A., counsel, Automobile Service Councils, Inc

96 Rendell, Edward G., Philadelphia City district attorney, National District Attorneys Association

48, 76 Richardson, Archie G., Jr., president, Automobile Owners Action Council

143, 171 Richey, Allen, executive vice president, Automotive Service Association .... 96 Rose, George, investigative counsel, Office of Consumer Affairs, National Association of Consumer Agency Administrators ..

298, 305 Stenson, Carl, service research, General Motors Corp

429 Stone, Daniel C., manager, motor vehicle inspection programs, Hamilton Test Systems, a subsidiary of United Technologies Corp

143, 144 Uzick, Mrs. Adolph, Houston, Tex.......

374 Vance, Carrol, district attorney of Harris County

354 Vogelheim, Karl, director, warranty administration, American Motors Corp

429 Warren, Glen, director, consumer relations, General Motors Corp

429 Weiner, Ron, president, Automobile Information Council

21 Welsh, Shelby, past president, Automobile Service Association.

340 West, E. O., Houston, Tex

376 Additional material submitted for the record byAutomobile Information Council-AIC:

Economic impact of the automobile industry in the State of Texas....... 23
Automobile tune-up by Champion Spark Plug Co...

29 Automotive Parts and Accessories Association, letter dated December 8,

1978, from Mr. Higgins to Chairman Eckhardt re mandatory licensing of
repair shops.

115 Automotive Service Councils, Inc., letter dated February 8, 1979, from Mr.

Cossette to Chairman Eckhardt response to ABC's position on Federal,
State or local laws mandating the licensing of auto repair shops....

99 Center for Auto Safety:

Letter dated January 4, 1979, from Mr. Ditlow to Chairman Eckhardt
re laws mandating the licensing of repair shops

121 Attachment 1-Letter dated January 27, 1978, Mr. Ditlow to Senator

Wendell H. Ford regarding problems consumers have experienced
with their automobiles

125 Illinois Attorney General's consumer fraud and protection division Chicago office, attachments to Mr. Benedetto's prepared statement: Exhibit 1-Attorney General William J. Scott, consumer fraud and protection division

421 Exhibit 2–Table 3.1-Satisfaction by purchase category

422 Exhibit 3—Table 5.6—Unremedied strong nonprice problems by purchase category .....





395 397

401 402 404 410

527 528






4 3

Statement of-Continued
Independent Garage Owners of Massachusetts, Inc.:

, Rich, president, Automotive Legislative Council of Amer-
ica, statement of
Letter dated December 13, 1978 from Mr. Florentine regards to auto

motive repair licensing,
Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, attachments to Mr. Kelley's
prepared statement:

Table 4-1-Vehicle damage assessment–Test No. 11
10 mph front into side average of all vehicles.
Attachment A-Excerpt from Insurance Institute for Highway Safety

press release, March 17, 1970
Attachment B—The highway loss reduction status report.
Attachment C-Price estimating for 1971, 1975, and 1978
How HLDI ranks the 1978 cars in collision losses ..
Attachment A-Costs to repair crash test damage for comparable 1978

and 1979 models
Attachment B-Examples of technology
Attachment C-Insurance Institute for Highway Safety 1979 model

low-speed crash test results ..
Attachment D- Estimated costs to repair 1979 models in 5-mile-per-

hour crashes
Attachment E—Estimated costs to repair 1979 models in 10-mile-per-

hour front to rear crashes
Attachment F-Insurance Institute for Highway Safety 1979 model

low-speed crash tests vehicle bumper system weights....
Letter dated December 8, 1978, from Mr. Miller to Mr. Berndt re speed

crash test program
Interstate and Foreign Commerce Committee, Subcommittee on Consumer
Protection and Finance:

Chart-Automobile related prices and the cost of living 1972-78

Table-Automobile related prices and the cost of living 1972-78
Motor and Equipment Manufacturers Association, William A. Raftery,

Car's age influences maintenance .....
Unperformed maintenance: $5.4 billion in potential aftermarket

More than 40 percent of maintenance functions never performed
Among original-owner cars, those 3-plus years old represent 45 percent

of jobs never performed
Percentage of original-owner cars that have never had the product

Number of years it takes 50 percent of original-owner cars to have

product replaced at least once
National Automobile Dealers Association, appendixes to Mr. Mallon's
prepared statement:
Appendix A-Letter dated August 25, 1978, from Chairman Eckhardt

to Mr. Mallon invitation to participate in auto repair hearings
Appendix B-Statement of National Automobile Dealers Association.
Appendix C-National Automobile Dealers Association locations
Appendix D-Letter dated August 22, 1978, from Mr. Mallon to

Senator Ford with attachment......
National Body Shop Council, Automobile Service Council's, Inc., attach-
ments to Mr. Benck's prepared statement:
Letter dated March 1, 1978, from Mr. Orrico to Motor Trend Magazine

re auto insurance part III by Jack Scagnetti

Letter dated March 22, 1978, from Mr. Scagnetti, Mr. Orrico Letters submitted for the record by

Covington & Burling, Richard D. Copaken and John J. Donohue, counsel to

Houdaille Industries, Inc
White House, Esther Peterson, Special Assistant to the President for

Consumer Affairs
Statement submitted for the record by John Langhorne, Jr., president of

Trouble-Shooters, Inc


40 41




242 244 268


485 490




ORGANIZATIONS REPRESENTED AT THE HEARINGS American Automobile Association of Missouri, Larry A. Pipes. American Automotive Association, D. James McDowell

, managing director, automotive engineering and road services department. American Motors Corp.:

Hitz, Neil, general parts manager.
Mizak, Raymond M., general manager-service.

Vogelheim, Karl, director, warranty administration.
Attorney General's Office, David F. Bragg, Chief, Consumer Protection Division.
Automobile Owners Action Council, Archie G. Richardson, Jr., president.
Automotive Information Council, Ron Weiner, president.
Automotive Service Association, Shelby Welsh, past president.
Automotive Service Councils, Inc.:

Benck, Henry, president, National Body Shop Council.
Cossette, Richard, president.

Randall, Donald A., counsel.
Bureau of Automotive Repair, Douglas Laue, deputy chief, California State.
Center for Auto Safety, Clarence M. Ditlow III, executive director.
Chicago's Consumer Protection Agency, Sharon Gist, acting commissioner, depart-

ment of consumer sales, weights, and measures. Chrysler Corp., Francis G. Hazelroth, general manager, service and parts division. Downs & Sons Auto Service, Morgan Downs. Federal Trade Commission, Albert H. Kramer, Director, Bureau of Consumer

Protection. Ford Motor Co., Grant C. Chave, manager, service programs, Ford parts and service

division. General Motors Corp.:

Pansa, O. Robert, director, service section, consumer relations and service staff. Stenson, Carl, service research.

Warren, Glen, director, consumer relations. Hamilton Test Systems, Daniel C. Stone, manager, motor vehicle inspection programs. Harris County, Tex., Carrol Vance, district attorney. Houston Auto Service, Bill Canterbury, owner. Illinois attorney general's consumer fraud and protection division, Michael A.

Benedetto, Jr., chief, Chicago office. Independent Garage Owner:

Florentine, George A., executive director.

Richey, Allen, executive vice president, Automotive Service Association. Independent Garage Owners Association of Illinois, Inc., Anthony DeRosa, president. Insurance Institute for Highway Safety:

Kelley, Albert Benjamin, senior vice president.

O'Neill, Brian, vice president for research. Michigan Department of State Bureau of Automotive Repair, James D. Hunsucker,

administrative assistant. National Association of Consumer Agency Administrators:

Gregg, Barbara B., president.

Rose, George, investigative counsel, office of consumer affairs.
National Automobile Dealers Association:

Hunt, David, associate counsel.
McCarthy, Frank E., executive vice president.

Mallon, Robert P., president.
National District Attorneys Association, Edward G. Rendell, Philadelphia City dis-

trict attorney. National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence, Daniel C. Knapp, director,

operating programs. Texas Service Station Association, W. H. Ligon, managing director. Texas State Senate, Senator Ron Clower, chairman, subcommittee on consumer

affairs. Transportation Department:

Brownlee, Michael, director, Office of Automotive Ratings.
Claybrook, Joan, Administrator.

Livingston, Charles, Acting Associate Administrator.
University of Texas, Clarence Johnson, director, Texas Public Interest Research

Group Washington Center for the Study of Services, Robert M. Krughoff, president. Wisconsin Auto Collision Technicians Association Ltd., Robert Argall, liaison officer.




Washington, D.C. The subcommittee met, at 10 a.m., pursuant to notice, in room 2123, Rayburn House Office Building, the Hon. Bob Eckhardt, chairman, presiding.

Mr. ECKHARDT. The Subcommittee on Consumer Protection and Finance will be in session.

Today the subcommittee begins 4 days of hearings on auto repair. Hearings will be held in Washington and in two cities with automobile populations among the largest in the Nation, Houston and Chicago, regarding the entire range of problems and potential remedies associated with what the consumers of this Nation perceive as the auto repair problem.

Our witness list is comprehensive and includes those most knowledgeable in every aspect of the auto repair process, from matters of auto design, manufacturing defects, and warranty problems, through the interactions of consumers, State regulatory agencies, and the maintenance repair industry at the shop level.

The subcommittee will examine existing programs and recommendations of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, the Federal Trade Commission, and the Environmental Protection Agency that bear on this complex problem.

We will attempt to determine what the auto manufacturers are doing and can do to address design and manufacturing defects and to reduce consumer complaints about warranty repairs.

We will examine State and local programs as well as private sector approaches to the problems of unnecessary, incompetent, or fraudulent repair practices. And we will hear from experts in the public and private sector regarding the feasibility of automotive diagnostics as a systematic approach to the auto repair problem.

The automobile may well have more impact on the lives of Americans than any other single consumer product. At present, there are approximately 124 million passenger cars and trucks used primarily for personal transportation in the United States. Between the early 1960's and the early 1970's, private transportation costs grew from about 14 percent to about 19 percent of the average American family's consumption expenditures, and the cost of owning and operating our personal vehicles has risen at record rates since then.

Between 1972 and June 1978, the Consumer Price Index rose by 55.7 percent, reflecting an average annual inflation rate of about 7.7 percent. New car prices increased by less than this, but taking into account style changes, additional consumer options, and mandated safety equipment, the average consumer outlay for a new car has risen at about the same rate as the CPI.

Every other major automobile-related price index has risen more rapidly than the cost of living, including auto maintenance and repair, which has risen at an annual rate of 8.4 percent, well above the rate of inflation.

As a result of these trends, in December 1977, private transportation expenditures had equal weight with food in the urban working family's budget, about 19.3 percent of total spending. This has occurred in spite of the disproportionately large increases in the price of food and other basic necessities during this period.

Direct outlays on maintenance and repair of family vehicles now account for about half as much as maintenance and repair of the home. Auto repair and maintenance outlays are 86 percent as large as average spending for professional medical services, and more than urban working families spend for men's and boys' apparel or personal and educational expenses.

With these hearings, the subcommittee begins a broad program to discover and reduce the avoidable costs of basic necessities in the consumer's budget. We are approaching the auto repair area in an exploratory way, seeking to identify the problems and explore all of the alternative approaches to their solution. While we do not have any specific bills before us, the subcommittee will make findings which could lead to legislation.

At this point in the record, I should like to place an attached chart and table with respect to repair and other costs, and also inflation, having to do with the automobile.

[The following material was received for the record:)

« PředchozíPokračovat »